My Alpha experience – why I consider the course to be cynical and dishonest

The Independent recently ran an article gushing with praise for the Alpha Course, calling it “British Christianity’s biggest success story“. I can understand that in a world where results are what gets you noticed, but having attended an Alpha Course once upon a time, I still find it both appalling and wryly amusing that the church is putting so much weight on a course that’s so fundamentally dishonest.

HallelujahI went on the course at a time when I was feeling uncertain of my faith, the best part of ten years ago. I thought a return to the basics might be just what I needed, so I booked myself in and prepared to ask my questions.

Before I go any further, and to forestall common defences of Alpha, I want to emphasise that I was under no illusions about the theology of the course, but that was what I wanted at the time, and I desperately wanted to believe. I also know that courses vary massively in tone and content, even though this is against the wishes of Nicky Gumbel and Holy Trinity Brompton, but the course I attended worked through the standard videos and books. What I experienced was the very core of Alpha.

The first couple of weeks were pleasant and inoffensive. Gumbel’s video talks were relatively vague and platitudinous, but our group had some interesting discussions. Some knew nothing about Christianity, some knew quite a lot, and one guy was always asking about Islam, which was a bit odd, and suggested he was probably attending the wrong course. The one thing that puzzled me was that no one was prepared to correct obvious errors and misunderstandings.

WorshippersThat all started to change soon enough. When Gumbel introduced the Bible, suddenly all the fluff was moved to one side. A couple of weak, hackneyed arguments about the provenance of the Bible were rushed through as if they had a train to catch, and from that point on, it was expected that any question could be resolved by appealing to the Bible as an infallible book of rules.

It was also about this time that the course organisers started to get far more involved. From not correcting misunderstandings, suddenly they were pretty obviously starting to tell everyone what to think. I’ve since read Gumbel’s book on running an Alpha Course, and this is what they’re told to do – avoid correction or criticism for the first few weeks, then start hitting them hard with the party line. It’s a deliberate strategy.

When I’m asked to describe Alpha, the phrase I use most often is bait-and-switch. The whole thing is based on the idea of friendly discussion, but quickly becomes an RE lesson. We have some old fragments of parchment containing copies of Biblical texts, therefore we can assume that it’s all 100% true. We’re just going to talk about some issues, except for when we go off on the Holy Spirit Weekend!

The what? Yes, you read correctly – the Holy Spirit Weekend.

I could say a lot of things about the Holy Spirit Weekend. It’s undoubtedly clever, but I think it’s also deeply cynical and manipulative. Everyone goes away somewhere to learn about the Holy Spirit. Why do you need to go away for a weekend? Because the unspoken intention is that the new hothouse environment will facilitate a spiritual experience that will get you hooked. One session is even called “How can I be filled with the Holy Spirit?”

Girl in PrayerClever churches get some church members to come along as well, ostensibly to help out on a more intensive weekend, but it also has the handy advantage of helping to create the right atmosphere. A bunch of confused Brits aren’t an ideal group if you want to encourage ecstatic spiritual experiences, but throw in a few people who know the drill (trust me, there is one) and it tips the balance considerably.

The weekend is at the heart of the entire course. The first few weeks deal with some basic housekeeping and weed out timewasters, and then they want you to be hooked as soon as possible. So they take you off somewhere strange, fill the place with music and people speaking strange languages, and wait for the payoff.

After that, the rest of the course seems slightly dull, stacking additional layers on top of what’s previously been discussed. If you’re in by this point, you’ll lap it up. If not, it’s just more data on what Christians believe, which will probably leave you cold, but might possibly be enough to convince you to “graduate” to church at the end of the course.

You might have gathered that I’m not a fan. I think the course is dishonest in its advertising and its arguments, sometimes manipulative, and always cynical. Finding out quickly moves into being taught, and then into emotional exploitation in unfamiliar group settings, all step by step, like a frog being boiled alive.

If a recognised cult was behaving like this, you wouldn’t be surprised.

Images courtesy of SCapture, Mart1n and APatterson, used with permission

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

About Recovering Agnostic

I'm Christian by upbringing, agnostic by belief, cynical by temperament, broadly scientific in approach, and looking for answers. My main interest at the moment is in turning my current disengaged shrug into at least a working hypothesis.

5 responses to “My Alpha experience – why I consider the course to be cynical and dishonest”

  1. Robin Brunskill says :

    When I attended the Conference on Harmful Religion over a weekend at Kings College in London, it was pretty much a given that Alpha was cult-like. Is it an introduction to Christianity or is it an introduction to Montanism.. a cult that was banned in AD98 by the early church? The idea that you can “harness” the holy spirit so that it can “enter you” is ridiculous. If you want to know where that heresy leads, have a look on youtube at “The Toronto Blessing”… Holy Trinity Brompton encouraged the insanity of the “Toronto Blessing” and that was an evil thing to do to people. So are you walking away from Christianity if you see through an Alpha course? No. I think you are walking away from something that can lead to the horrific “Toronto Blessing” con. And it is only wise to do so.

  2. Robin Brunskill says :

    The (late) cult expert Dr Betty Tylden did used to help people who had got involve with HTB… and sadly, her contribution to the Harmful Religion conference was not allowed to be published, so I will repeat it here. What she said is that the true self and the “born again” self, end up in conflct, and this leads to mental breakdown.

  3. Tracey Hayter says :

    I agree very much with what Robin Brunskill is saying about Alpha. Because there is a famine for the truth of the word of God these days, most professing christians are in total ignorance of where Alpha is really leading, which is, of course, to the end-times interfaith apostate church. You say you had a christian upbringing so you probably know the basics and more, unless, of course, you are in your twenties and have parents who attended a church that was advocating the Toronto deception. There are few REALLY good Bible expositors around but some names to listen to are Bill Randles, Jacob Prasch, Roger Oakland and Warren B Smith – on youtube. All of them are very much into end-time prophecy and you will learn more from their teaching than you’re ever likely to learn in church these days. I hope you will come to a knowledge of the truth and find that which you seek.


    • Robin Brunskill says :

      Thanks for agreeing with me Tracey. And I make note of your point “unless you are in your twenties.” Quite by chance, I went to St Mary’s Marylebone in the evening, a few months ago. I didn’t know it was a charismatic church. I was truly shocked by the way the congregation were manipulated into a trance-like state and then encouraged to “get the holy spirit to do things for you.” The young man leading this (to me) occult-style spell-casting, was a person that I’d chatted with before the “Ceremony” and he DID have parents who were involved in the Toronto Blessing. So he would have been brought up to think that all this was Christianity. It was a very disturbing experience. I wrote to them the next day to try and reason with them, and I even sent them a book list. Obviously, they took no notice. They were polite, but had no clue as to where they were leading people. Truly the blind leading the blind. Frightening.

  4. Steve James says :

    Hi! I have Just noticed this blog and I was pleased to find that we came to a similar conclusion. I made a video about this course which has become its main opponent on You Tube. I hope you get time to check it out as I would be interested in your opinion. Nice blog, by the way!
    Video link –

Love it? Hate it? Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: